Female Talk

A safe place for women to discuss news, issues, and politics

You are here

Got Milk? Launches Sexist Ad Campaign

Replies

erika's picture
Submitted by erika on

The worst part is that if a woman really IS a psychotic harpy right before her period? That's a sign of PMDD, which is a medical condition that can - and should - be treated.

But as long as crazy mood swings are considered "normal" (much less the butt of easy jokes) a lot of women will be doomed to live in untreated misery. Not realizing that it ISN'T normal to go crazy one week a month.

Thanks, Milk Council!

Robyn Jane's picture
Submitted by Robyn Jane on

PMS: Putting up with Men's Sh*t.

Ever notice out worst problems begin with men? Menstruation, menarche, menopause.

Danielle's picture
Submitted by Danielle on

Call me crazy, but I actually found these ads to be quite funny. In my experience with my female friends, the stereotypes that are in these adds are true with some of them. A few of my friends get really bitchy when they're PMS'ing ... and others go through this odd depression, and a couple others just get whiney. I don't understand it.

When I have my period nothing happens. I don't experience sadness or anger or irritability. I don't get cramps either. When I'm on my period, I'm the same as when I was not on my period. My period is just another thing that happens---I could even compare it to a bruise that you don't even know you had until you look at it (nothing changes except your knowledge of its existence). I do tend to get hungrier when I'm on my period, but that's it.
I have two other girl friends who are similar to me--I can't even tell when they're on their period unless they tell me they are ... or I find evidence of it (tampon in purse, etc ...)

Sometimes I wonder if people just use the "Period" as an excuse to do all the things they felt they couldn't do when they were without their period (ie. get angry, tell people off, cry, sleep more, get people to cater to their every need, etc...). 

Got a little off topic just then ... but anyway ...

Considering my experience, I can see the humour in it. I think people need to take a chill pill once in a while and find the hilarity in the ad.
I can see the guys side of PMS ... and it's similar to what these adds present. My Dad often feels he does everything wrong when my mom is PMS'ing--and I can understand because my Mom is quick-to-snap and quick-to-blame when it's her time of the month.

That being said, because of the overkill and redundancy of the adds, I can also see a little sexism as well. Although stereotypes are formed by something true--to push them forward and make a certain sector of the public look "bad" for it is wrong.
If they had simply make one or two of these adds, all would be fine--it's just a little comic relief. Three and more is overkill, which ... unfortunately, they did.
 

erika's picture
Submitted by erika on

The advertising industry wants to trivialize PMDD (silly women with their wacky hormones!) but it's a serious disorder. And it's treatable with behavioral changes, antidepressants, and CBT (cognitive behavioral therapy).

No woman needs to live with being a crazy-ass monster every month. It's not normal, despite what ads like this want to make you believe!

k's picture
Submitted by k on

Got Milk ads have always been misogynistic, so this is nothing surprising.

Funny how the guys in this series of ads aren't sexualized and shown in submissive and degrading poses - no milk mustache or anything. But they're there to supply white liquids for their woman's every need, aren't they...

It bothers me more that we barely see any advertisements from a female gaze. What you see in these ads is the perspective of a sane individual (aka male) who tries to make sense of women's minds. We don't see advertisements that show how emotionally inept men can be, or how weak/inexperienced they are in many situations. You might see some specific types of men, but the point is that there's a variety of portrayals in the media of them. They're not lumped into one group, because they are shown as individuals...

Leave a Reply

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <i> <b> <img> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <div> <strong> <p> <br> <u>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.